Its strength is the characters, with chapters that shift the point of view, but marketed as horror it turns out to be a thriller with few scary scenes, an increasingly uneven score and a lore about the weapons that explains the what but not the why. An extremely subjective film, bound to divide audiences.
Weapons is a not-quite-horror film written and directed by Zach Cregger, the filmmaker behind Barbarian, produced by New Line Cinema and released in theaters in August 2025, starring Julia Garner, Josh Brolin and Alden Ehrenreich. It is set in Maybrook, a quiet little town in Pennsylvania, where one night, at the very same hour, the children of an elementary school class walk out of their homes and vanish into thin air.
The community's suspicions immediately fall on the children's teacher, Justine Gandy, who in the meantime starts investigating what happened. As the film goes on, each chapter puts a different character in the spotlight: from Justine we move on to Archer Graff, the father of one of the missing children, and so on, all the way to the final climax, which is the story of the only child in the class who did not disappear.

The most interesting part is the characters. The film tells the town's story from many points of view, moving through characters you would never suspect, yet tied together by a common thread that the viewer has to piece together to get the full picture of the film and truly understand the meaning of the title, "Weapons", and of the concept of a "firearm". The screenplay is quite reminiscent of Christopher Nolan's style, but in a far less epic vein.
At first the film has good sound, but then it becomes more and more uneven. Its contradictions show up in the following scenes as well: promoted with a horror trailer, the film turns out to be a thriller, because it has very few scary scenes (and they mostly happen in nightmares). As I already said about Companion, a heavy thriller component can take the edge off a film's horror, but having thriller scenes at the expense of horror ones is not necessarily a flaw.

The main flaws become apparent once the film is over, and they leave a bitter taste in your mouth. The film does not fully manage to explain the origins and the lore behind the concept of the weapon. Part of it is made clear, and we get to know the villain who uses these weapons, but something is missing. The film explains what a weapon is, but not why it exists.
All in all, it is a watchable film, but do not let other people's views fool you. Watching Weapons is extremely subjective, as the sharply divided opinions show, and the film risks splitting its audience.